Man Killed by Brother Was Missing Eye; Cops Find Cup of Blood, ‘Blood-Smeared’ Eating Utensils, Plate: Docs

Hertgen (above left), 31, was beforehand charged with first-degree homicide, varied third and fourth-degree weapons offenses associated to possession of a knife and golf membership and one depend of third-degree animal cruelty in connection to the demise of his youthful brother, 26-year-old Joseph Hertgen’s (above proper), and a cat.

Post-mortem outcomes are pending; Joseph’s demise is being handled as a murder. Matthew faces 30 years to life in jail and a superb of $200,000 for the first-degree homicide cost alone.

In line with the courtroom docs, through FOX Information Digital, Matthew known as 9-1-1 simply after 11:15 pm on February 22. Throughout the name, he stated there was a fireplace and useless physique inside his house, figuring out the deceased as his brother whereas saying he had been useless for about 30-40 minutes.

“I am not gonna get into any extra particulars proper now,” he allegedly stated when requested how his brother was injured, earlier than reiterating that assertion when pressed on whether or not any weapons had been used within the incident.

Matthew allegedly met officers on the door once they arrived, earlier than Joseph was discovered useless on the eating room flooring, “with a big pool of blood round his head and torso.” Per the docs, Joseph sustained extreme blunt pressure trauma to the again of his head; he additionally had what was described as a “massive laceration” to his proper eye, whereas his proper eyeball “was not seen.”

On the eating room desk, close to the physique, was one other disturbing sight.

“Moreover, patrol officers noticed a cup of what they believed to be blood, together with blood smeared consuming utensils and a bloody smeared plate,” reads the docs. Officers additionally say they discovered a useless cat, partially burned and in addition struggling blunt pressure accidents, on an ottoman in the lounge.

In line with the affidavit, as Matthew was being positioned into handcuffs, he was requested how he sustained “abrasions and scratches” on his arms. He allegedly informed officers that he “went right into a match of insanity … possibly like forty minutes in the past.”

The docs additionally shine some mild on the following investigation into Joseph’s demise, with one other Hertgen brother telling authorities Matthew “suffered from extreme psychological sickness” for 5 years — and stated that when he noticed Matthew earlier the day of the homicide, he was “extraordinarily distressed, despondent, and skilled terrifying visions.”

Involved about Matthew, the brother picked him up round 4:30pm and was with him till about 10pm that evening. He then introduced Matthew to the house in query — the place he noticed his brother Joseph alive for the final time — earlier than leaving him there. The brother allegedly messaged Joseph that Matthew was having “visions,” telling him to message him if he wanted any assist.

Joseph allegedly responded, “Will do,” however the brother did not hear from him once more. The brother additionally texted Matthew an invitation to affix him on a hike the following day, telling him to “hold in there,” however did not hear from him both. 45 minutes after that, Matthew known as 9-1-1 to report Joseph’s demise.

Per FOX Information Digital, Hertgen appeared in courtroom on Thursday and agreed to stay behind bars till his trial.

Matthew performed on the boys’s soccer workforce at Wesleyan College earlier than he graduated in 2015. His brother, Joseph, additionally performed soccer for the College of Michigan till his 2019 commencement.