Are degrees still relevant in Singapore’s evolving job landscape?

After I was rising up, getting a college diploma was by no means a query. All through my main and secondary college years, I attended quite a few tuition and additional courses to complement what I had realized at school.

The top aim of this? To safe admission to a prestigious tertiary schooling establishment. Wanting again now, my economics diploma solely has marginal relevance to my present job, if any in any respect.

It’s to not say that my college expertise was solely futile — the years I spent pursuing my diploma undoubtedly outfitted me with a strong basis in ideas resembling market buildings and financial insurance policies.

However in the case of the particular information and expertise required for my career, I discover myself relying extra on the sensible experiences and on-the-job coaching I’ve acquired over time.

I’m not alone on this predicament, although. Throughout the city-state, solely a mere seven per cent of Singaporeans with post-secondary {qualifications} really feel that their instructional {qualifications} are “very related” to the job they presently maintain.

However given this reality, why do many nonetheless relentlessly pursue greater schooling certifications?

Extra Singaporeans possess post-secondary {qualifications}

The idea that schooling is essential for a brighter future is deeply rooted in Singaporean society, which stems from its meritocratic system.

With good grades, you will get into a superb college. With good college grades and a superb diploma, you possibly can land an ideal, high-paying job. In different phrases, schooling paves the way in which to success in Singapore.

This is the reason many Singaporeans really feel as if they’re caught in a rat race from a younger age, resulting in a major enhance within the variety of college graduates over time.

As of 2020, almost six out of 10 Singaporeans aged 25 and above have a post-secondary, diploma, skilled qualification or college stage credentials, up from lower than half the inhabitants in 2010.

Notably, the most important contribution to this total enhance comes from the proportion of college graduates, which has surged by 9 proportion factors, rising from 23.7 per cent in 2010 to 33 per cent in 2020.

Youthful age teams, notably these aged between 25 and 34, show the very best charges of people with a minimum of post-secondary {qualifications}, with 9 out of 10 possessing such credentials. The development continues inside the 35 to 44 age bracket, the place greater than eight out of 10 people achieved the identical instructional milestone.

Nonetheless, the notion amongst Singaporeans {that a} college diploma equated to success isn’t wholly ungrounded although — that’s in case you tie success to the amount of cash one earns.

College graduates do, in actual fact, earn considerably greater salaries. In keeping with Seedly, graduates of their 20s and 30s earn a median pay that’s a minimum of greater than double in comparison with these with out greater schooling {qualifications}, in addition to these from the Institute of Technical Schooling.

Graduate unemployment is a urgent challenge

Whereas this can be the case, an vital issue to contemplate when analyzing the pursuit of upper schooling is the diminishing worth added from a college diploma because the variety of graduates will increase.

Take real-world instances for instance — a level can enhance incomes by over 20 per cent in sub-Saharan Africa, the place levels are comparatively uncommon, however in Scandinavia, the place 40 per cent of adults have levels, it boosts earnings by solely 9 per cent.

As post-secondary {qualifications} turn out to be commonplace, recruiters and employers will more and more demand them, regardless if they’re really required for a particular job. This creates a scenario the place many jobseekers really feel compelled to pursue greater schooling regardless of their profession objectives or pursuits.

On the identical time, the ample Singaporeans with post-secondary schooling additionally means that there’s a excessive provide of jobseekers who’re “over-educated” — which, in flip, results in unemployment because the variety of obtainable jobs usually are not proportional to the variety of job seekers.

For example, Singapore noticed a rise in graduates who remained unemployed for greater than six months after leaving college, regardless of recording greater median salaries in 2022 as in comparison with the earlier 12 months.

In parallel, nations resembling China are additionally seeing youth unemployment hitting document highs this 12 months, with 20.4 per cent of job seekers aged between 16 and 24 unable to seek out work regardless of having greater schooling {qualifications}, with some possessing credentials from abroad establishments.

The case of the “graduate poor”

With graduates unable to safe jobs, a lot of them are turning to “low-skilled” jobs that provide decrease salaries. Primarily, these graduates are underemployed.

In keeping with a survey performed by the Lee Kuan Yew College of Public Coverage and Ong Teng Cheong Labour Management Institute, about 4.31 per cent of degree-holders in Singapore are severely underemployed.

These graduates earn than lower than S$2,000 a month, regardless of holding full-time jobs. “These are the ‘graduate poor’, and it’s a black swan in our labour panorama,” mentioned Zainal Sapari, an assistant secretary-general with the Nationwide Trades Union Congress (NTUC).

Even then, for individuals who handle to safe a “high-skilled” job, there’s typically a mismatch between their instructional {qualifications} and job scope.

Solely 13 per cent of Southeast Asians really feel that their instructional {qualifications} are “very related” to the job they presently maintain. In Singapore, this determine was drops to a mere seven per cent — the bottom throughout the Southeast Asian area.

This highlights the hole between the talents acquired by formal schooling and the evolving wants of the job market, particularly in Singapore.

Academia shouldn’t be catching up with the evolving job market

The difficulty with academia is that it simply can not sustain with the evolving job market, particularly with the rise of synthetic intelligence (AI) and automation. Typically instances, institutes of upper schooling don’t equip graduates with the fitting expertise wanted for the office.

The truth is, seven out of 10 younger Singaporeans are uncertain or don’t suppose the tertiary schooling they obtain in Singapore prepares them sufficiently to affix the workforce.  

Six in 10 professionals in Singapore’s workforce echo the identical sentiments, believing {that a} diploma holds much less significance in touchdown a job immediately, as in comparison with 20 years in the past.

Moreover, a Harvard Enterprise Overview report finds that the correlation between schooling stage and job efficiency is weak. In any case, educational grades are solely indicative of how a lot a candidate has studied.

Recognising this paradigm shift, employers are actually putting larger significance on particular skillsets fairly than relying solely on educational {qualifications}.

In Singapore, information from a LinkedIn analysis revealed that extra firms choose to rent candidates with technical expertise (39 per cent) and transferable expertise (31 per cent), over schooling (eight per cent) and minimal years of expertise (12 per cent).

However why are expertise extra beneficial than educational {qualifications} immediately?

AI has drastically modified the job panorama

AI instruments, together with chatbots resembling ChatGPT, have quickly and drastically modified the job panorama immediately. These instruments will depart an enduring influence in varied industries, disrupting the way in which we work.

For one, it should end result within the lack of sure jobs, however on the identical time, it could even be the catalyst for the creation of latest jobs that require completely different skillsets.

With automation changing varied job features, its vital to select up expertise which are arduous for AI to copy, resembling creativity, emotional intelligence, important considering, and problem-solving — smooth expertise that require human judgement, instinct and empathy that aren’t simply replaceable by machines.

Automation apart, smooth expertise are additionally a vital a part of bettering one’s capacity to work with others. The capability to collaborate successfully with colleagues and domesticate optimistic relationships inside an organization performs a vital function in skilled development and success.

Though the rise of AI has led to a rise within the demand for IT-related expertise, an IBM examine has discovered that the largest ability gaps immediately usually are not digital, however behavioural.

That mentioned, arduous expertise resembling digital expertise can nonetheless be simply picked up by varied different means, as a substitute of attending an institute of upper schooling. The rise of on-line schooling due to the pandemic has democratised entry to arduous expertise, making it extra accessible and reasonably priced for people to accumulate information in varied fields.

On-line programs provided by respected establishments just like the Massachusetts Institute of Know-how (MIT) typically present sensible, up-to-date information that’s instantly relevant to the job market in a shorter time period, offering a profitable various to levels that prices hundreds of {dollars}.

The significance of steady studying

I do admit although, universities and different tertiary establishments have been upping their recreation to equip their college students with smooth (and arduous) expertise, however these are normally within the type of programs that span just a few weeks, resembling NUS’ Roots and Wings course.

These expertise positively require information, however it’s actually extra about motion — which is why hands-on expertise holds larger worth than simply merely buying information on these expertise.

At this time, 73 per cent of all professionals and younger Singaporeans together with Gen Zs, are prioritising expertise over levels.

However past buying the required arduous and smooth expertise required for a job, it’s vital to recognise the significance of adaptability and steady studying because the job panorama evolves to turn out to be extra advanced and risky.

Within the wake of latest improvements, steady studying is not a alternative, however a necessity. It holds the important thing to staying up to date with the most recent business traits, buying new expertise, and remaining aggressive within the job market.

Throughout his speech on the World Lifelong Studying Summit final 12 months, Singapore’s Minister of Schooling, Minister Chan Chun Sing, acknowledged that “no quantity of entrance loading in [Singapore’s] college system could be enough for the lifelong schooling wants of Singaporeans”.

This is the reason the Singapore authorities has upped its efforts to advertise lifelong studying by initiatives resembling SkillsFuture.

Levels nonetheless have their place in Singapore

Nonetheless, that isn’t to say that there is no such thing as a worth in a level, particularly in the case of specialised fields resembling medication, finance, and regulation.

Levels in such fields are sometimes the spine of those specialised profession paths, and supply a strong basis of information and rigorous coaching that’s important for fulfillment and security in these professions.

For example, to turn out to be a Registered Psychologist in Singapore, you wouldn’t solely have to finish an undergraduate diploma, but in addition receive a masters within the area.

Whereas this holds true, it’s simple that the worth of a level has considerably deteriorated within the context of Singapore’s job panorama immediately.

Though institutes of upper schooling are adapting to this altering panorama by incorporating programs to reinforce college students’ workforce readiness, the tempo of change stays a problem.

The speedy evolution of the job market necessitates a complete method to schooling and profession growth, one which goes past conventional classroom studying and embraces steady upskilling and real-world expertise.

Featured Picture Credit score: pexels